Skip to Content

Homemade Christmas Recipes – Yellow Rose Designs

Mock Apple Pie (aka: Cracker Pie)

Greetings from Texas! I’m Kat from Yellow Rose Designs. I consider myself a multi-preneur, having started no less than 3 businesses during the past couple of years. I make handmade jewelry and crafts, create designs for products from t-shirts to binders and stationery (with the help of an amazing artist who does custom designs for me), and have recently re-launched my web design business building WordPress and blog themes and custom Facebook tabs.

I’m so excited to have the opportunity to share another great passion of mine. Cooking. While there are several versions of this recipe around now, this one was handed down to me by my Grandmother. I’ve modified it a bit to make my own semi-homemade version using pre-made roll out pie crusts. It’s still a family favorite at holiday time. The story goes that when our family first moved to Texas, they were really missing the apple pie they’d had “back East”. (This would have been around 1844 or earlier, before Texas was a state.) So they came up with a recipe using what they had – Soda Crackers and cinnamon. It’s been a family tradition to have this pie for Thanksgiving and Christmas in our family all these years, so I’m glad to be the one baking it for the family now.

Here’s the recipe as it was handed down to me by my Grandma. Soda Crackers = Saltine Crackers. And a hint – DO NOT use low sodium crackers in this recipe. Notice how it doesn’t call for additional salt? There’s another, similar recipe using Ritz crackers, but IMO, this one is the better recipe. Then again, our family has spent generations perfecting it. They should know.

1 1/2 Cups Water
1 1/2 Cups Sugar
1 1/2 teaspoons Cream of Tartar
18-20 Saltine Crackers, broken in large pieces
1/2 teaspoon Cinnamon
1/2 Stick (4 Tablespoons) Stick Butter or Margarine (I prefer Land O Lakes brand)
1 1/2 Tablespoons Lemon Juice
2 Uncooked Pillsbury Roll-Out Pie Crusts (1 package) or any 9″ Roll-out pie crusts
Extra butter, cinnamon and sugar to sprinkle on top of the pie as desired
Deep 9″ Pie Pan
Medium sized saucepan

Open the packages of pie crust and let them warm to room temperature before taking them out of the package.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees (F).
Roll out 1 pie crust into 9″ pie pan. Set aside.
Break Saltine crackers into large pieces.

cracker pie cracker pie
Mix water, sugar and cream of tartar in medium saucepan. Bring to a boil.
Add broken saltine crackers. Reduce heat to simmer.
cracker pie
Add remaining ingredients (cinnamon, butter, lemon juice).
cracker pie
Simmer 2-3 minutes until butter is melted. Stir gently not to break up the soft pieces of cracker too much. It should look similar to this:
cracker pie
Pour mixture into uncooked pie shell.
cracker pie cracker pie
Cover with 2nd pie crust. I lay it on one side of the pan still rolled up and roll it out across the top.
cracker pie
Vent (poke with a fork); and seal edges (fork tines make a great fluted seal).
Trim excess crust around pie pan after sealing the edges.
cracker pie
If desired, brush with a little melted butter, sprinkle cinnamon and sugar over top.
cracker pie
Bake at 350 degrees (F) for 30 minutes.
Allow to cool.

Tips for making a great Cracker Pie and have a little fun. Do not use low sodium crackers or unsalted butter. It’s better to use stick butter in the recipe, but melted tub butter or margarine works fine to brush over the top of the pie. Roll out pie crusts are much easier to use at room temperature, so be sure to get these out early and cut the ends of the plastic off to let them warm up inside their packaging. There are no good substitutions for the recipe (I’ve tried several) other than using a cinnamon/nutmeg mix for the cinnamon and to sprinkle on top. Do not leave ingredients out or it won’t have the right flavor. I use a nice, deep 9 inch pie pan for this pie. When cutting the extra crust around the edge, I like to use a small paring knife and cut in one direction with a single smooth cut. The crust will shrink during baking, so lean the knife out a little as you cut. If you need metric measurement conversions, Food Network has a great conversion chart:

To have a little fun if your family or co-workers have never had Mock Apple Pie, don’t tell them the main ingredient of the pie, but have them guess. (I do let people know it isn’t gluten free in case someone has allergies.) Most will guess apple right away, but it’s fun hearing what you could have substituted for the “apples” when you tell them that isn’t it. I’ve heard pear, peach, even pineapple but no one ever guesses Crackers!

Enjoy, and Happy Holidays! Thank you, Michele for allowing me to share this favorite family recipe with everyone!
cracker pie cracker pie

I have started truncating my posts to avoid having my content stolen. I hope you’ll click over to finish reading the post. Thank you for understanding!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Wednesday 15th of December 2010

I have heard of this before but never tried it. Hmmm - I might have to give this one a go. Definitely would be fum to take to a church dinner.


Tuesday 14th of December 2010

Thank you for your kind comments on my recipe. @Debby, I hope it's as good as your grandmother's recipe. That would make my grandma very proud. :)


Tuesday 14th of December 2010

Another clever recipe! I love it!

Beverly @

Tuesday 14th of December 2010

This is too funny. My daughter and I made one of these and gave it to family members and told them it as an apple pie. No one even questioned it!!We had a great time with it!


Tuesday 14th of December 2010

Oh my goodness, I almost cried when I saw this recipe. My grandmother made these pies and they were my favorite. Yummy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.