Skip to Content

Pottery Barn Knock-Off Pillows

I have a fun pillow makeover to share with you today! 
Back in the spring I found the most amazing ginormous pillow at Rugged Wearhouse for only $5. It was a blank canvas just waiting to be transformed. I scoured Pottery Barn for inspiration pillows and stumbled across two that would look great in my living room: the poppy pillow and the lavendar monogram pillow.
Both of these pillows are embroidered and, if you’ve ever visited my blog, you know that I DO NOT sew. But that’s okay. I had other plans to get these looks!
I used colors that would match my living room (red, olive, and gold) for each side of the pillow.
(Yes, in case you didn’t realize, I put both of these designs on the same pillow. I love reversible projects!)
IMG 1468
Let’s start off with the pillow itself. Like I said, its ginormous! 2 ft x 2 ft. Seriously!
IMG 1472
Next up, let’s talk about the poppy side of the pillow.
I remember (way back in the day) in high school doing a very fun project in my Spanish class involving Huichol yarn art. Its a technique of creating a design using yarn and moving the yarn in such a fashion as to give your artwork movement. I loved it! And thought it would be perfect for this project.
I scoured several stores looking for the “right” yarn. I tried to find some that looked crocheted to match the Pottery Barn pillow better, but ended up finding this fun ribbed yarn in all of the right colors.
IMG 1474
I printed off a full 8.5″ x 11″ image of the pillow to use as a guide, found a starting point on my pillow, and proceeded to draw out my first poppy.
I drew one poppy at a time, filling each in with yarn befor moving on to the next because adding the yarn actually made the image slightly larger than the original drawing. I didn’t want to mess up my spacing and wind up overlapping my images!
Also, I only drew the outline of the red part of the poppy because I knew it would eventually be completely covered with yarn in the end and the marker would never be seen.
I adhered all of my yarn with my favorite fabric adhesive, Fabri-Tac from Beacon.
(This stuff is seriously amazing. Better than a glue gun!! I swear!)
IMG 1513
The turquoise line in the above photo represents the outline of the flower (where I drew it with the marker). I always did the outline of the flower first with the yarn then went back and filled it in the rest.
The orange line with arrows represents how I filled in my yarn. There was no specific technique. I just wanted to create movement by keeping the yarn in what would look like a swirly manner.
After finishing a flower with the red yarn, I went back and outlined it with the green yarn. I saved the stems and leaves until the end so I would not overlap them with any of the flowers I had yet to create.
IMG 1475
I stopped periodically to compare my version to the Pottery Barn printout and check out my progress.
I was really starting to see it come together!
IMG 1499
After finishing with the red and green yarn, I went back to fill in the centers of the fabric with the gold yarn. I tied a knot in the yarn then, to thicken it, tied two more knots on top of the original knot. I trimmed off the knots and layered them in the centers of some of the flowers.
IMG 1505
I love the texture the yarn adds to the pillow.
IMG 1504
IMG 1502
I ended up leaving off the little flowers that Pottery Barn scattered around the pillow.
I really like the extra white space and the asymmetric look.
For the monogram side of the pillow, I took some liberties from the Pottery Barn version and instead of using a lavendar plant, I used a poppy floral design to help tie it into the reverse side of the pillow.
I created the design on my computer then separated the images into two so I could cut them out using my Silhouette.
 I cut my images out on freezer paper to iron on and use as a stencil. I ironed down the floral design first. The little detail images in the poppies were so tiny that I just left them off. I did, however, keep the detail images in the smaller flowers.
I still had all of my acrylic paint from my Custom Wall Art project from last year which is also in my living room so I already had on hand the paint colors I would need. I mixed the paint with some acrylic paint fabric medium and went to work.
Once the floral design was dry, I went back and ironed on the M freezer paper stencil and painted it also.
This side of the pillow literally only took a couple of hours to complete, including drying time. Whereas the poppy side of the pillow took a good 6 hours or so!
IMG 1510
IMG 1511
Can you see that I traced around the M with a fabric pen?
Since my pillow was prestuffed with no way of getting the stuffing out without ripping out threads and resewing, I just painted on a stuffed pillow. Probably not the greatest for freezer paper stenciling, but it worked okay. I just used the fabric pen to tidy up the edges of my monogram.
IMG 1506
So let’s do a tally!
Pottery Barn Poppy Pillow: $49
Pottery Barn Lavendar Pillow: $29
Total: $78
Pillow: $5
Yarn: ~$4 each so $12
Glue: $5
Paint and Medium: $4
Freezer Paper: $5
Fabric Pen: $4
Total: $35
I had the paint, freezer paper, and fabric pen on hand already so really my total could be ~$22!
Not bad, especially considering it is completely customized to match my living room!
Note: I do not let my children near this pillow. Just in case, you know? 🙂
Feed Mail FaceBook Twitter Pinterest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Karren Haller

Wednesday 20th of February 2019

Thank you for sharing on Wonderful Wednesday, it has been pinned and shared on Instagram. Please stop by and share again! Have a great week!


Tuesday 19th of February 2019

Really neat idea! The pillow turned out perfect. Happy Crafting, Kippi #kippiathome


Monday 11th of February 2019

WOW! I am so impressed with this pillow!! I don't think I would have the patience to do something like this, but it's incredible.

Danielle Miller

Tuesday 19th of November 2013


Michele {The Scrap Shoppe}

Sunday 1st of January 2012

April, I don't let anyone on the pillow! Its strictly for decpr. The monogram side would be fine to lay on, but the yarn side wouldn't be able to hold up to day-to-day use. My pillow still looks great today! :)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.